Homeowner requests clearer direction from committee members _ san marino tribune
The San Marino Design Review Committee attempted to provide more clarity to Ken Wiley, owner of a single-story home at 677 S. Home decorating tips living room Santa Anita Ave., regarding design changes that would help the proposed two-story Cape Cod house receive the advisory body’s approval.
The DRC unanimously continued Wiley’s case to the committee’s Feb. Interior home designs photo gallery 1 meeting to allow him time for modifications to the proposed house’s roof, square footage, lighting and doors and windows.
“This is becoming a quite costly and frustrating process,” Wiley complained to the committee at its Dec. Home decorating ideas on a low budget 21 meeting, which was the third hearing for the proposed house.
“I think we’ve done pretty much everything that’s been asked of us in this process…and we come back and there’s a detail that wasn’t brought up in previous meetings,” Wiley said in response to comments from DRC Vice Chair William Dietrick, Member John Dustin and Alternate Member Judy Johnson-Brody.
“When this house first started out in this committee everyone commented that it was out of place in terms of its size and massing in that location,” Dustin said.
“They’ve gone very aggressively after the height of the house, but really the interior living volume has been unchanged,” he noted, giving Wiley and his architect credit for their efforts to address cosmetic issues.
“Visually, this house, in that location with its neighboring homes, looks substantially bigger and just addressing that one issue of the height of the roof causes other problems with the appearance of the project,” Dustin added, stating that reducing the roof height is not a good way to solve the proposed house’s massing.
“I think that what, to me, still needs to be considered is a little bit more of a symmetrical look,” she said. Homemade cake decoration “When you look at it straight on, everything in the house—all five windows and the doors—are symmetrical and then part of the house is hanging over by what looks like it could be two or three feet.”
“I would look for a window and door system that is fully coordinated. Home decoration photo malaysia I would look for lighting that is a little bit closer into the upstairs doors so it doesn’t look as awkward,” Johnson-Brody suggested, recommend ing that one of the two light fixtures around the recessed entry way on the front façade be removed.
“I don’t really care about the square footage. Traditional indian home interior decoration You’re allowed a certain amount. Interior home design colors You’ve worked within that and I’m fine with that. Home decor ideas pinterest diy You’ve worked very hard to lower the height of the house. Home decoration ideas india When you stand there it is no different than the house to the [north] of it,” she added.
Square footage was an important issue for Vice Chair Dietrick, who noted that the 3,683 square foot house was far from the legal neighborhood average of 3,008 square feet.
“I just can’t get over the square footage. Decoration home magazine I think that it’s large compared to the houses on the street,” he said. Home decor ideas tumblr “It needs to be decreased in size a little bit to fit better on that street and preserve the streetscape of Santa Anita Ave.”
In response to Dietrick’s concerns, Wiley stated, “I think there’s a lot of focus being placed on the house to the south of us and not enough focus being placed on the houses behind us and to the north of us, which are two-story houses and larger in square footage.”
“For me it’s not really an issue of the number of the square footage. Home decoration tips india It’s the appearance of the house visually,” he noted. Interior design home remodeling “This proposal would be the second largest house in that legal neighborhood.”
The DRC also unanimously continued an application for a new detached three car garage, front yard fencing and other exterior modifications to its Feb. Home interior decorating books 15 meeting.
“The materials selected by the applicant are not found in that neighborhood,” Committee Member Corinna Wong said. Interior home decorating styles “There’s a lot of vinyl fencing and that’s not a material I want to see cropping up in our city”
The committee did not support replacing the existing brick driveway with a concrete driveway, stating that it would result in too much concrete in the front yard.
“Concrete is visually more striking than brick,” Dustin explained. Homemade things for decoration Dustin added that six proposed light fixtures at the rear of the house would produce too much light.
“I would call this an 80s stucco house, which probably, to me, was the worst era of home building,” Johnson-Brody said of the proposal, noting that the proposed 18-inch by 24-inch wood columns would be too large.
In regards to the homeowner’s proposal to remove wood siding from the house, Johnson-Brody stated, “you’re taking a house that has beautiful wood features and turning it into a stucco box, and then you are taking brick out and you’re putting more concrete in and it’s just lessening the neighborhood and the house itself.”
Vice Chair Dietrick agreed with his colleagues and encouraged the homeowner’s representative, Michael Cheng, to review the city’s residential design guidelines with his clients.
“It’s not a problem, I knew it was going to happen” he said of the hearing’s outcome, noting that he told the homeowner that many of the proposed design changes would not work in San Marino.
The Design Review Committee denied a proposal to construct a new two-story Spanish Colonial Revival house on Durklyn Ct., which is a cul-de-sac.
“Most of the [residents] on Durklyn Ct. Home decoration photos india actually are for us doing this home. Home interior design hall And they’re looking themselves to do something larger, so they’re looking to this house to see what will happen with city approval,” Volbeda said.
“If you make a decision to okay this two story house, you’re setting a precedent for all the cul-de-sacs with 1950s single story ranch [homes],” she said.
“When you are looking either to the left or the right of this home, you do see two-story homes, but on Durklyn itself there are no two-story homes,” she said.
“It is a very beautifully-designed home,” Johnson-Brody added. Home interior decoration photos “It would increase the value of the homes of that neighborhood. Interior home decor accessories It may concern some people in San Marino because it may be a precedent for other two-story homes, but I honestly think this would be a beautiful home.”